Mark Pritchard, Proctor & Gamble’s CMO has asked Publicis, WPP and Omnicom to create a hybrid consumer agency to service a portion of his North American business. The collaboration, he hopes, will yield better creative and better economics. (Insert silent giggle here.) When the boss asks for something and is willing to pay for something, you do it. Mr. Pritchard is the boss and the biggest ad spender in the neighborhood.
As proof of concept, he points to the wonderful anti-advertising Tide Detergent campaign aired during the last Super Bowl. But there’s a massive problem with the logic. Ad people are very ethnocentric. Very egocentric. Did I mention competitive? Especially creative people. Leonardo da Vinci let some talented interns mix the paints and sketch on some canvases, but he wasn’t collaborating.
Every time someone trots out this hybrid agency idea or the idea to have a totally dedicated brand shop, it’s failed. As Faris says, “ideas are recombinant.” Egos aren’t.
This dedicated agency model may save money, it may make a couple of goods ads, but it won’t attract the best people and certainly won’t foster the best creative. Ring around the agency.
Tags: faris, Faris Yakob, Hybrid P&G agency, mark Pritchard, new P&G ad agency, omnicom, Proctor and Gamble, publicis, ring around the agency, tide detergent, tide super bowl campaign, whats the idea, whatstheidea, wpp
July 12, 2018 in Marketing
In the toast at my daughter’s wedding I plan on sharing a smidgeon of marital and parenting advice. A brand planner by trade, I make a living observing behavior then packaging it into small, memorable bits of advice. Toast advice number 1. Don’t use the “H” word. Both my kids should remember this one; it’s […]
July 11, 2018 in Marketing
I’d like to say when it comes to brand planning my philosophy is “listening” but it’s not. Many will tell you the best cultural anthropologists are listeners, observers and silent recorders of behavior. They are. Many brand planners today are expert listeners but not all see. Watching confirms what the ears hear. Observing can add […]
July 10, 2018 in Marketing
My baby girl is getting married in a couple of months and I’ve been wondering what to say in the toast. Stuff about her? Everyone in the room knows her. Stuff about her soon-to-be-husband? Many will know him better than I. Should I lead with a joke? I’m funnier extemporaneously than when I write material. […]
July 6, 2018 in Marketing
Not sure if this is an apocryphal story or not but it certainly sounds legit. There is a 10 A.M, Delta flight out of LaGuardia weekdays that flies into Bentonville, AR home of Walmart. Anybody who is anybody in retail, I’m told, has been on this flight known as the Bentonville Bus. If you want […]
July 5, 2018 in Marketing
Kandee Johnson is a supratypical “Posters.” Different than a Paster, a poster is an original content creator on the web. I first ran into Kandee while researching an assignment on Plus White teeth whitener, a national consumer brand out of New Jersey. Kandee was a blogger and vlogger with an amazing following of young women. […]
July 3, 2018 in Marketing
The most powerful cognitive trait on the planet is learning. Animal’s learn where to feed. Insects learn how to procreate. Children learn to associate pain with danger. Learning is everywhere. Except in brand strategy. At What’s the Idea? learning is a fundie. It has been a peeve of mine for years that most advertising is […]
July 2, 2018 in Marketing
Google is an interested animal. I play it like a violin, but it takes practice. The key to using Google to your advantage lies in selecting and posting phrases. Unique phrases. Ehr-ee-body plays in keywords. Phrases, however, are ownable. To start, find what you feel is a meme-able phrase and post it to your site. […]