Mark Pritchard, Proctor & Gamble’s CMO has asked Publicis, WPP and Omnicom to create a hybrid consumer agency to service a portion of his North American business. The collaboration, he hopes, will yield better creative and better economics. (Insert silent giggle here.) When the boss asks for something and is willing to pay for something, you do it. Mr. Pritchard is the boss and the biggest ad spender in the neighborhood.
As proof of concept, he points to the wonderful anti-advertising Tide Detergent campaign aired during the last Super Bowl. But there’s a massive problem with the logic. Ad people are very ethnocentric. Very egocentric. Did I mention competitive? Especially creative people. Leonardo da Vinci let some talented interns mix the paints and sketch on some canvases, but he wasn’t collaborating.
Every time someone trots out this hybrid agency idea or the idea to have a totally dedicated brand shop, it’s failed. As Faris says, “ideas are recombinant.” Egos aren’t.
This dedicated agency model may save money, it may make a couple of goods ads, but it won’t attract the best people and certainly won’t foster the best creative. Ring around the agency.
Tags: faris, Faris Yakob, Hybrid P&G agency, mark Pritchard, new P&G ad agency, omnicom, Proctor and Gamble, publicis, ring around the agency, tide detergent, tide super bowl campaign, whats the idea, whatstheidea, wpp
April 23, 2018 in Marketing
In one of Hilary Clinton’s campaign speeches on the topic of “playing the women card’ she uses a meme-able statement “Deal Me In.” She liked it so much she used it repeatedly in her Democratic National Convention speech. In context, it was a wonderful, powerful sentiment. It became a campaign theme and meme. A […]
April 20, 2018 in Marketing
Social Media is a great tactic for marketers. But how great is yet to be determined. There’s a famous quote from John Wannamaker who once said, and I paraphrase, “I know half of my advertising is working, problem is, I’m not sure which half.” If retailer extraordinaire Wannamaker says only half his advertising is working, […]
April 19, 2018 in Marketing
The hottest advertising topic of the day is digital ad privacy. Mark Zuckerberg brought his suit to Washington last week to answer questions about privacy before Congress and now those interested understand they can turn privacy settings on. Where and how to do it may be a bit of a slog, but at least they […]
April 17, 2018 in Marketing
When I ask new clients “What is your product strategy?” I get a funny look. Typically, they respond with something like “Make the best possible product, meet the specific needs of the customer, and provide it with a level of service the exceeds their expectation.” Or some such goulash. Even service companies will use similar […]
April 13, 2018 in Marketing
Kylie Jenner’s makeup sold $420 million in 18 months with minimal advertising beyond her Instagram posts. Her lip kits and eyeshadow palettes, at one point, retailed for $27 and $42 respectively. At a street fair on Long Island teen girls were falling over themselves to buy the stuff. The police showed up after a while, […]
April 12, 2018 in Marketing
“According to several studies, showing or simply feeling gratitude has mental health benefits, including promoting a happy frame of mind.” The New York Times, Of Interest column, 4/12/2018. As I think about all the brand strategies I’ve written, I’m hard pressed to come up with a claim and proof array that ties to gratitude. […]
April 11, 2018 in Marketing
Mark Pritchard, Proctor & Gamble’s CMO has asked Publicis, WPP and Omnicom to create a hybrid consumer agency to service a portion of his North American business. The collaboration, he hopes, will yield better creative and better economics. (Insert silent giggle here.) When the boss asks for something and is willing to pay for something, […]