Monthly Archives: June 2009

Same old GM.

0

 

 

There’s a new General Motors TV spot created by Deutsch breaking tomorrow that is, amazingly, the same old-same old.  More freaking upbeat music, more “moving forward” imagery, no remorse, no apology, no mention of chapter 11, though the spot does spin the word “chapter.”  It’s pretty much like watching any GM corporate spot over the last 20 years. (In fact, I’d love to pair some old voice overs with this film just for grins.)

 

The new GM according to copy will be “leaner, greener, faster, smarter.” Blah cubed.

 

The most powerful image in the entire spot is a huge sculpture of a metal fist suspended in air paired with the voice over “and fix it we will.”  Very USSR. It happens, though, to be the only emotional point in the spot that resonates.  

 

Here’s what I want in a chapter 11 spot. Leadership. I want acknowledgement that the company was out of touch and I want to hear what it is doing to stay in touch. I want a demonstration that the new company has good judgment, not blather about reinventing itself. Whenever I screw up I’ve found the best way forward is to admit it. To myself… then to those I’ve let down. I don’t do a song and dance about it and a God damn plié. PEACE!

 

Adgorithm

0


The adgorithm is the new breed of online advertising that is driven by statistics rather than media and creative professionals.  The adgorithm allows testing of online ad units in seconds to see what words, colors, pictures and ideas click through at the highest rates. The adgorithm is also a media testing approach where data hounds (be they agency-based or in-house) employ ad exchanges to let the adgorithm predict performance and make media placement choices.  Soon the machines will even replace the data hounds. You listening Sarah Connor?

 

I’m a big science guy when it comes to marketing, but science needs a creative baffle. The greatest, most nerve-wracking part of working at an ad agency is the conflict between creative and logical minds. It’s where “new” comes from. As statisticians and data nerds become more important in the marketing business, I’m afraid we’ll have an even further melt-down. We’ll lose serendipity. We’ll talk ROI even more than we do now.  Strategy isn’t something an adgorithm can create. Marketing strategy is about future sales, it’s predictive. We really must temper the adgorithm before marketers start getting addicted. Then all will be lost. Peace!